Дементьев Н.В., Кузьмин Р.И. Построение модели влияния внешней трудовой миграции на экономическую безопасность региона
Дементьев Николай Викторович,
кандидат экономических наук
Тамбовский филиал Российской академии народного хозяйства
и государственной службы при Президенте Российской Федерации,
г. Тамбов, Россия
Dementyev Nikolay V.,
Ph.D. in Economics
Tambov branch of the Russian Presidential Academy of National
Economy and Public Administration,
Tambov, Russia 
E-mail: Этот адрес электронной почты защищен от спам-ботов. У вас должен быть включен JavaScript для просмотра.
Кузьмин Роман Игоревич,
кандидат педагогических наук
Тамбовский филиал Российской академии народного хозяйства
и государственной службы при Президенте Российской Федерации,
г. Тамбов, Россия
Kuzmin Roman I.,
Ph.D. in Pedagogy
Tambov branch of the Russian Presidential Academy of National
Economy and Public Administration,
Tambov, Russia 
E-mail: Этот адрес электронной почты защищен от спам-ботов. У вас должен быть включен JavaScript для просмотра.
УДК 331
Аннотация: В статье рассматривается влияние внешней трудовой миграции на демографическую ситуацию в Тамбовской области.
Ключевые слова: трудовая миграция, демография, экономическая безопасность, социально-экономическая политика.
Abstract: The paper considers the impact of external labor migrants on the demographic situation in Tambov region.
Key words: labor migration, demography, economic security, social and economic policy.
Russia is actively integrating into the world of economic order and migration regime supporting it. The restructuring of the Russian economy and employment is in line with the prevailing global trends.
In modern conditions of the Russian economy development the flows of external labor migrants have considerably increased and it is primarily due to the collapse of the Soviet Union, which turned internal migration flows between the former republics into external.
Undoubtedly, the presence of immigrants in the country effects the economic security of the state. This impact can be both negative and positive.
The following factors of external labor migration have a negative impact on the economic security:
1. Currency export from the Russian Federation. According to some experts, about 50 % of the immigrants send a half of the money they earn to their homeland (mainly in US dollars). At the same time, few of them use the services of the banking system [1].
2. Excessive concentration of migrants within a particular area can lead to political and social destabilization, as well as to narrowing of access to housing and social services. Due to the fact that some, often a significant portion of migrants can not get a job or does not work in their specialty, a threat of loss or irrational use of migrants' qualifying potential becomes real, there is also a threat to reduce their motivation to work [2].
3. The influx of a large number of migrant workers, those who are not always able to get a job, with its mass character and isolation from the local population, may create the country's inter-ethnic tensions and conflicts.
4. Illegal labor migration conditioned by originality of the existing model of social and economic transformation contributes to the formation of the vast informal sector in the Russian economy, which produces about a quarter of GDP [3].
5. The illegal use of foreign labor leads to high losses in government revenues due to non-receipt of the fee for the use of foreign workers, employers tax evasion. At the same time illegal immigrants use the tax paid infrastructure.
6. The impact of the informal flow of illegal migrant workers in the areas with low and slow pace of socio-economic development leads to the deterioration of the material and cultural living conditions of the native population, the difficulty of newcomers adapting, aggravation of the crime situation. This, in turn, leads to additional costs from the state and local budgets for law enforcement, and maintenance of social infrastructure.
7. Damage caused by persons staying illegally on the territory of Russia, affects both the economic situation of the country and the increase in crime. Crimes committed by foreign citizens and stateless persons take a large part in the general crime structure.
8. The threat to the health of Russians. Illegal migrants can be carriers of many infectious and epidemiological diseases forgotten in Russia. Difficult economic situation, the lack of health care policies, and fear of deportation deprive migrants of the possibility to seek professional medical help [4].
But not always external labor migration is negative. For example, some authors believe that the issue of competition between migrants and the Russians in the labor markets is of the special urgency. You can often find the opinion that this competition is quite fierce, and that this circumstance crucially influences the attitude towards immigrants. We think that such judgments are often caused by ignorance, prejudice, or political speculations. We can agree that in certain areas of the economy some jobs have become migrant, as they were "reserved" for them. But it does not usually mean that they were captured in the competition [5].
According to research conducted by foreign scientists, there is an active function of immigration, which is manifested in the fact that immigrants create additional demand for goods and services immediately upon arrival, and thus increase the demand for labor regardless of the fact whether they started to work or not.
It is known that many migrants are employed in low-paid and not prestigious works in the areas of employment, where the Russians do not want to work in. According to many experts, migrant workers occupy only those niches that are voluntarily ceded by the local people. "Russian youth will no longer work on a construction site, on a conveyor belt, sell potatoes and bananas in the market - the level of education will not make it possible."
Thus, in our view the most acceptable theory is that migration does not have a negative impact on unemployment of the local population of the region and the country as a whole. Of course, we can't say that nowadays there is no competition for jobs between migrants and the local population at all, but if it exists, then only in a small amount. In our opinion, this problem will be solved in a few years, as the level of education increases each year, and as we mentioned above, young professionals will not put in for low-paid and not prestigious jobs. In turn, foreign labor migration will help to solve a number of economic problems, including those related to the labor shortage.
Besides, the influx of unskilled migrant workers is beneficial for the people of Russia as the under-payment for their work contributes to the reduction of prices for goods and services. If we consider this concept from the standpoint of enterprises, low-skilled immigrant labor is a mean of reducing costs and providing certain competitive advantages in the market. Employers who hire them to work, tend to get significant savings on labor, which allows to obtain higher profits. The positive effect for the employer from the use of immigrant labor at the micro level is receiving income while minimizing the costs of their work using, which can serve as an additional source of investment in the national economy. In addition, at the macro-level migrant workers in Russia have a positive impact on the tax component ensuring the flow of indirect taxes and contribute to an increase in aggregate demand in the country.
The influx of highly qualified and intelligent migrants also have a positive impact on the Russian labor market and, consequently, economic security as a whole.
Another positive effect of external labor migration on economic security is that immigration has slowed the reduction of human resources in Russia and thus it is to a large extent mitigated the impact of this reduction. As a rule, people migrate at a younger age, which has a positive effect on the age structure and promotes fertility.
The intensity and direction of migration flows, as well as their degree of influence in different regions is not the same, therefore, some individual methods should be applied to each region. At the moment, we are interested in the situation with the influx of foreign labor migrants in Tambov region.
For clarity, we have calculated a model of external labor migration impact, in conjunction with natural population growth on the demographic situation in the region. Data for the model are taken from official sources [6]. Table 1 and Fig. 1 reflect the natural and mechanical growth of the population of the Tambov region for 8 years.
Table 1
The Dynamics of Growth / Decline in Population in the Region
Based on the results of our research we have determined that, if the total natural growth of the native population of the region is 1 person, demographic situation worsens within the prospective decline in population of 13 people, and with every increase in population on 1 "guest worker" promising number should grow by another person. Every migrant worker who comes to the region attracts another one or gives birth to another one. However, the significance of these findings turned out to be negligible (less than 10%). Therefore, we examined the particular models of demographic dependence on native people's birth and death, as well as arrival and departure of migrant workers.
We have built four particular cases of the model mentioned above: I) native people are born - migrants arrive; II) native people die - workers leave; III) native people are born - workers leave; IV) native people die - migrants arrive. The results are shown in Table 2.
Table 2
Summary Table of the Results of the Construction of Private Demographic Models
Now we would like to explain our results. The model III is the most significant (70%) of all our models. Its qualitative interpretation is as follows.
Every native person born in the region will ensure the natural increase of the population at the level of 23 people in the long term, but such a result is possible only if at the same time one migrant leaves the region territory. His leaving will result in the drift of 5 more migrants. Thus the situation being discussed provides population growth of 18 people in the long term.
The opposite situation with the reliability of 42% which is also pretty much illustrates the continuation of total population decline in the region: the birth of a native person of the total with the arrival of one migrant attracts prospective decline in population in the region of 1 person.
We have also considered two cases associated with increasing mortality of native people. In these cases, we believe, will be the demographic diffusion, i.e. the positive direction of the substitution of native visitors. However, these models are unlikely, as follows from the table 2.
Thus, improving demographic and economic security in the region requires policies aimed at increasing the birth rate giving priorities to the native population of the region, that should result in spontaneous expulsion of labor migrants out of occupied socio-economic niches.
1. Официальный сайт Министерства внутренних дел Российской Федерации. URL: http://ru/news/9046/ (Дата обращения: 15.06.2015).
2. Проект "Русский Архипелаг". URL: http://www.archipelag.ru/agenda/povestka/povestkaimmigration/trud/ekonom_bezopastnost/ (Дата обращения: 15.06.2015).
3. Метелев С.Е. Международная трудовая миграция и развитие российской экономики. М.: Юнити, 2006.
4. Глушенков А.М., Теневые миграционные процессы в системе обеспечения экономической безопасности // Аудит и финансовый анализ. 2007. Вып. 4.
5. Федотов В.В. Россия: проблемы трудовой иммиграции // Общество и экономика. 2008. Вып. 1.
6. Официальный сайт УФМС России по Тамбовской области. URL: http://fms.tambov.gov.ru/ufms/statistic (Дата обращения: 15.06.2015).