Рейтинг@Mail.ru
Arzamastseva_012014
СИСТЕМА ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫХ ГАРАНТИЙ ГРАЖДАНСКИХ СЛУЖАЩИХ ТАМБОВСКОЙ ОБЛАСТИ И ЕЕ СОВЕРШЕНСТВОВАНИЕ КАК ФАКТОР ПОВЫШЕНИЯ ЭФФЕКТИВНОСТИ ГРАЖДАНСКОЙ СЛУЖБЫ

THE SYSTEM OF STATE GUARANTEES FOR CIVIL SERVANTS OF TAMBOV REGION AND ITS IMPROVEMENT AS A FACTOR OF INCREASING THE EFFICIENCY OF THE CIVIL SERVICE
 
Арзамасцева Алина
Тамбовский филиал Российской академии народного хозяйства
и государственной службы при Президенте Российской Федерации,
г. Тамбов, Россия
Трифонов Юрий Николаевич,
кандидат философских наук
Тамбовский филиал Российской академии народного хозяйства
и государственной службы при Президенте Российской Федерации,
г. Тамбов, Россия
Arzamastseva Alina
Tambov branch of the Russian Presidential Academy of National
Economy and Public Administration
Tambov, Russia
Trifonov Yury N.,
Ph.D. in Philosophy
Tambov branch of the Russian Presidential Academy of
National Economy and Public Administration
Tambov, Russia
E-mail: Этот адрес электронной почты защищен от спам-ботов. У вас должен быть включен JavaScript для просмотра.
 
УДК 35.08

Аннотация: В статье рассматриваются системы государственных гарантий для государственных служащих Тамбовской области. Выявлен ряд недостатков в сфере законодательства.
Ключевые слова: государственные служащие, гарантии, компенсации, субсидии, поддержка.
Abstract: The paper deals with the system of state guarantees for civil servants of Tambov region. It considers some disadvantages in the sphere of legislation framework concerning the issue.
Key words: civil servants, guarantees, compensation, subsidy, support.

As it’s known, the efficiency and effectiveness of civil servants depend on the availability of a complete system of state guarantees and real mechanisms for their support.
The basis of the modern institution of state guarantees in the civil service of the Russian Federation is in the rules of the Chapter 11 "The State Guarantees in the Civil Service" of the Federal Law of July 27, 2004 № 79-FL "On the State Civil Service of the Russian Federation" [1] (hereinafter - the Law on the Civil Service of the Russian Federation). First of all, as it’s defined in Art. 52 of this law, the state guarantees for civil servants are aimed at:
a) providing legal and social protection of civil servants;
b) increasing the motivation for effective discharging of their duties;
c) strengthening the stability of the professional staff of the civil service;
g) compensating of limits established by the law. [2]
An important feature of the state guarantees in the civil service is the fact that the law divides them into basic (Art. 52) and additional (Art.53). It is obvious that the state guarantees make sense when they are not only embodied in the laws, but also have a real mechanism for implementation. In this regard, G.A. Malysheva emphasizes the need for a mechanism of the state guarantees implementation at the civil service as a set of organizational, social and legal measures for ensuring the fulfillment of the civil servants duties in a professional manner, as well as contributing to civil servants motivation. [3]
The guarantees of civil servants of Tambov region are embodied in Art. 8 of Tambov region of 30.03.2005 № 304-L "On Organizing the Civil Service of Tambov region." [4] First of all, it is said that "civil servants of Tambov region are provided with the basic state guarantees established by the federal law." Thus, the basic state guarantees are fully applicable to them, as defined in Art. 52 of the Law on the Civil Service of the Russian Federation.
For realizing some of them the relevant laws of Tambov region were passed. So the procedures, conditions and amount of expenses compensation related to official business, expenses compensation related to relocation of civil servants and members of their families to another place when removing a civil servant to another state structure are governed by the following laws:
- The law of Tambov region of October 31, 2006 № 96-L "On the Procedure and Conditions of Secondment of People Substituting Public Positions in Tambov Region, and Civil Servants of Tambov Region";
- The law of Tambov region of April 3, 2008 № 355-L "On the Procedure and Conditions for Reimbursement of Costs Associated with the Relocation of a State Civil Servant of Tambov region, and Members of his Family to Another Place under Conditions of Removing the State Civil Servant of Tambov region to Another Public Body of Tambov Region."
In addition, for the development of safeguards regarding public pensions, they adopted the law of Tambov region of July 25, 2009 № 558-L "On long service pension of people holding public office and municipal, state and municipal employees of Tambov region."
According to Art. 8, Part 2 of Tambov region of 30.03.2005 № 304-L "On the Organization of the Civil Service of Tambov Region," apart from the basic state guarantees, civil servants of Tambov region are provided with the following additional state guarantees:
1) the appointment of a civil servant to a post in the civil service procedure career development on a competitive basis, the inclusion of civil servants in the talent pool on a competitive basis, the rights to job-protected vocational training, skills development and training are guaranteed in accordance with the results of the certification;
2) transport services provided in connection with official duties, depending on a category and group of the substitutable position of the civil service, in the cases and manner established by the regulatory legal act of Tambov region;
3) the possibility of replacing some civil service positions in the same public body or another public body on the assumption of the elimination of the public body, its reorganization or a change in its structure and reduction of the staff, depending on the level of qualification, vocational education and public service period or work (service) by profession;
4) compensation in the amount of four months salary in the case of dismissal of Tambov region civil servants, substituting positions for a fixed term, which is limited by the period for persons holding public offices, if there is an early termination of the powers of the persons concerned;
5) the annual government allowance for rehabilitation at the request of a civil servant in one of the following grounds:
- In case of providing a paid annual leave (any part of it), and on conditions that the leave conforms to the labor legislation of the Russian Federation - in the amount of two months salary fixed at the beginning of the leave;
- In the case of temporary disability, confirmed by relevant documents - in the amount of two months salary fixed at the date of calculation of the government allowance for rehabilitation.
The government rehabilitation allowance is not paid to the civil servants, who came to the civil service in the current calendar year from state or local authorities and have already received the government allowance for rehabilitation (a similar payment conforming to the legal act of the public body, local authority) in the current calendar year in the former place of service.
The civil servants, who have not exercised their right to receive the government rehabilitation allowance in the current calendar year, get it on application in the case of dismissal in order of transferring to another public body.
6) the government support when improving the living conditions in the manner established by the normative legal act of Tambov region;
7) providing one-time subsidy for the purchase of a residential area in the manner and on the terms established by the legislation of Tambov region in sphere of housing;
8) mandatory state insurance in the cases, manner and amount established by the legislation of the Russian Federation.
Significantly, that in addition to the Law of Tambov region of 30.03.2005 № 304-L "On the Organization of the Civil Service of Tambov Region" some guarantees are provided to civil servants of Tambov region in accordance with other regulations. Such an example could be the Law of Tambov region of 30.01.2004 № 194-L "On the social guarantees for people who held certain government positions, civil service positions of Tambov region and terminated the powers (job functions)."
The analysis of organizational and regulatory framework for supplying and providing civil servants with guarantees revealed a number of risks and unsolved problems in this area:
1) at the federal level:
a) many important guarantees for civil servants still have not received proper legal and regulatory framework. Thus, according to Art. 52, Part 3 of the Law on the Civil Service of the Russian Federation civil servants are provided with other state guarantees established by the federal laws. However, federal laws do not establish by far any other guarantees for civil servants;
b) regulations establishing appropriate guarantees for civil servants, are scattered in the normative acts, which complicates their enumeration and correct understanding;
c) not all state guarantees are supplied with a security mechanism. In particular, there are almost no mechanisms for implementation other additional state guarantees provided by paragraph 5 of Art. 53, the Law on the Civil Service of the Russian Federation.
For improving legislation in the sphere of civil servants state guarantees, it is necessary to unify the existing laws in this area by adopting a separate Federal Law "On the State Guarantees of civil servants of the Russian Federation." The adoption of such an act, i.e. creating a reliable legal framework, would give consistency, integrity, and completeness to the institution of civil servants state guarantees. [5]
2) at the level of the subject of the Russian Federation (in particular, Tambov region):
a) they did not realize the requirement of Art. 52, Part 1, subparagraph 7 of the State Civil Service of the Russian Federation concerning the payment of the compulsory insurance in cases, manner and amount prescribed by the laws of the Russian Federation.
In the original version of Art. 8, Part 1 of Tambov region Law of 30.03.2005 № 304-L "On the Organization of the State Civil Service of Tambov region," it was said that the order, conditions and size of payments for government rehabilitation allowance are established by the Law of Tambov region. Currently, this provision is excluded and Part 2 of Art. 8 is amplified with subparagraph 8 as follows: "cases, procedure and amount of compulsory state insurance are established by the legislation of the Russian Federation"
In this instance we can hardly agree with this decision of the legislators of Tambov region, as compulsory state insurance is the basic guarantee, but the Law of Tambov region refers it to the number of additional guarantees, with no real mechanism to ensure, but only with reference to the legislation of the Russian Federation.
b) they did not create a security mechanism for the standard implementation of subparagraph 6, Part 2, Art 8 of Tambov region of 30.03.2005 № 304-L "On the organization of Tambov region civil service," which stipulates that public support in improving the living conditions is regulated in the order established by normative legal act of Tambov region;
c) they did not adopt a Law of Tambov region determining the order and conditions of providing civil servants, appointed by staggered elections to civil service positions in government bodies located in other areas, with service accommodation, as well as the procedure and amount of compensation given to civil servants of Tambov region for accommodation hiring (sublease).
Thus, the mechanism for the implementation of state guarantees in the civil service is a set of organizational, social and legal measures for ensuring that civil servants fulfill their duties in a professional manner, as well as contributing to civil servants’ motivation.
The state guarantees for government employees are provided at the level of the Russian Federation, and at the level of the RF subjects. However, many important guarantees of civil servants still have not received adequate mechanism of implementation.

References:

1. О государственной гражданской службе Российской Федерации: федер. закон от 27.07.2004 г. № 79-ФЗ // Собрание законодательства РФ. 2004. № 31. Ст. 3215.
2. Воробьев Н.И., Галкин В.А., Мокеев М.М., Осипова И.Н., Юдина А.Б. Комментарий к Федеральному закону от 27 июля 2004 г. № 79-ФЗ «О государственной гражданской службе Российской Федерации» (постатейный) // Подготовлен для системы Консультант Плюс, 2012.
3. Малышева Г.А. Государственные гарантии гражданских служащих: современное административно-правовое регулирование и направления совершенствования: Дис. …канд. юрид. наук. Воронеж, 2012.
4.Тамбовская жизнь. 09.04.2005. №68.
5. Малышева Г.А. Государственные гарантии гражданских служащих: современное административно-правовое регулирование и направления совершенствования: Дис. …канд. юрид. наук. Воронеж, 2012.